Back to homepage
MyChart
Used as main image by Phynd in search results and profile page

Luke Mahlon Nightingale, MD

Family Medicine

Provider Ratings

4.9 out of 5 (140 ratings)

Provider Groups

  • Innovative Health Alliance of New York

  • SPHP Medical Associates

Primary Contact

518-664-3242
Online Scheduling
Appointments (New Patients Welcome)
Online Scheduling
Provider Groups

  • Innovative Health Alliance of New York

  • SPHP Medical Associates

Primary Contact
518-664-3242
Print Share

Services & Specialties

Areas of Specialization

  • Family Medicine

Locations & Contact

Primary Location

Stillwater Family Health Center

1111 Hudson Ave
Stillwater , NY 12170

View hours
Monday
8:00am - 4:00pm
Tuesday
8:00am - 4:00pm
Wednesday
8:00am - 4:00pm
Thursday
8:00am - 4:00pm
Friday
8:00am - 4:00pm
5186643242 View Details

Education & Certifications

Board Certifications

Family Medicine, Family Medicine, American Board of (1989)

Provider Groups

Innovative Health Alliance of New York

SPHP Medical Associates

Provider Ratings

The following ratings and reviews are based on verified feedback collected from independently administered patient experience surveys. The ratings and comments submitted by patients reflect their own views and opinions. Patient identities are withheld to ensure confidentiality and privacy. Learn More >

4.9 out of 5

(140 ratings)

The Patient Satisfaction Rating is an average of all responses to the care provider related questions shown below from our survey. Patients that are treated in outpatient or hospital environments may receive different surveys, and the volume of responses will vary by question.

161 Reviews

09/23/2024

It was a very good visit from the front desk to the nurse to DR Nightingale all of them are very respectable listen to my concerns for my son and his concerns and we’re all good

09/12/2024

He always try’s to listen to Angel when something bothers her like she hates the tongue stick, so as long as she opens wide and listen he doesn’t make her use it.

08/19/2024

Dr. Nightingale is very focused on disease prevention, which I appreciate. This approach allowed my cancer to be discovered early.

08/12/2024

They are there for me when ever I need them

08/01/2024

Excellent experience

07/24/2024

Allways helpful and courteous

06/21/2024

As a patient for over 30 years, Dr. Nightingale always listens to any concerns I have and provides the medical advice necessary to recover from my medical issue (or refers me to a specialist).

04/19/2024

I have been with dr. Nightengale for several years and have always been very pleased with his professionalism and compassion for caring for people.

04/09/2024

I am able to get an appointment whenever i need one.

03/28/2024

HE LISTENS, PROVIDES ANSWERS AND MAKES IT EASIER TO ASK DIFFICULT QUESTIONS. ALSO HELPS ME TO UNDERSTAND HEALTH ISSUES AND WHERE TO GET ANSWERS THAT ARE NOT IN HIS FIELD.

03/15/2024

great

02/27/2024

Glad to see mentoring a medical school student

02/15/2024

Very professional and caring

02/14/2024

The best doctor i have had in years. Really cares about keeping you well!

02/05/2024

Great provider

01/24/2024

excellent dr my health improved in many ways

01/04/2024

Dr. Nightengale is terrific. I can't say enough.

01/03/2024

VERY ATTENATIVE TO THE NEEDS OFTHE PAITENT

12/14/2023

Dr Luke is a good person .He listen and give advice .And send me to good Dr when needed.thanks

12/11/2023

Very knowledgeable, and friendly.

12/07/2023

Dr Luke is so wonderful and caring

12/06/2023

Great Place

12/04/2023

TOOK TIME TO TALK WITH ME AND LISTEN

11/21/2023

Oh, very professional, but not over done

11/04/2023

Would highly recommend this to my friends and family or anyone looking for honest great treatment.

11/02/2023

I was treated with high respect

11/01/2023

I recommend this practice to everyone

10/30/2023

Very good doctor!

10/29/2023

The staff is always very helpful and efficient.

10/27/2023

every thing went fine

10/13/2023

I have had nothing but extremely positive experiences with everyone. Thank you!

10/13/2023

Dr. Nightingale has that ability to put you at ease right away. He listens to your concerns and explains everything to you thoroughly. His nurse is very kind and capable

10/11/2023

My nurse, Molly, is a true joy to work with at Stillwater Family Healthcare and so is the doctor.

09/27/2023

Enjoyed

09/26/2023

When Dr. Nightengale retires he will be very missed. The next doctor has big shoes to fill.

09/26/2023

World recommend this practice. We need more of what Dr. Nightingale and his team provides across a healthcare system that appears to have become more institurionalized and less focused on quality of care.

09/23/2023

Excellent experience

09/22/2023

Will definitely come back again

09/19/2023

Check records and responded accordingly

09/18/2023

Respectful of my privacy, answers all questions and concerns

09/12/2023

Overall a great experience with all of the staff

09/12/2023

Proficient in his field outstanding in his questioning.

08/31/2023

Nice and professional

08/29/2023

We are new to the area but the times that we used the services of this office we have been very satisfied

08/22/2023

Spending time with a patient is very important to me n also reduces anxiety

08/16/2023

Has always been a great Doctor!

08/09/2023

Very comprehensive

08/04/2023

Always top notch professional experience

08/02/2023

Attentive, informative and caring

07/08/2023

Excellent care and timely service

06/27/2023

Immediately responded to my needs

06/27/2023

He’s very good could explain a little more

06/19/2023

always gets me right in to the office

06/16/2023

Really friendly comfortable visit

06/15/2023

Looks for other answers.

06/12/2023

I've been going to Dr. Nightengale's office for years. Wouldn't have if it were otherwise.

06/05/2023

I actually look forward to my next visit!

06/03/2023

He listens to what the patient says gets great advice

06/01/2023

Very helpful and pleasant staff.. Dr Nightingale patient and takes time to explain things.

05/24/2023

Dr Nightingale was patient, understanding and kind. He’s very knowledgeable.

05/20/2023

HE WAAS CONCERNED AND TOOK TIME TO SHARE WITH ME

05/19/2023

He is very kind

05/14/2023

Nurse Molly is exceptional in caring for patients and putting them at ease. Dr Nightengale continues to provide excellent care

05/04/2023

I am very happy Luke is my primary physician.

05/01/2023

Everyone was exceptional

04/26/2023

great help

04/23/2023

This was my first visit and i need help, however i dont know if i will get what i need. I hope so.

04/20/2023

He is very thorough, and does not judge.

04/17/2023

He has been my primary care doctor for so many years that I am confident with any diagnosis or referral he indicates.

04/15/2023

Easy to talk too

04/12/2023

Very nice office people and doctor

04/07/2023

Doctor is rude, opinionated and did nothing to even TRY to solve my issue

04/07/2023

Been their a couple times and both times were great

04/03/2023

Woulf highly recommend him

04/01/2023

I always feel comfortable at this office.

03/31/2023

Kind and very professional services. I feel they care.

03/31/2023

I trust him and his diagnosis.

03/16/2023

I would like to continue with Dr. Luke for my primary health care.

03/09/2023

Very glad with they do their job .

03/01/2023

It's nice to be confident in the doctor you see. It's a comfort no stress. He's a very calming caring doctor

02/26/2023

Vary helpful

02/06/2023

Dr. Nightingale really does listen to patients.

01/27/2023

Always cares about the patient, and listens to everything you say and takes you seriously

01/22/2023

Very pleased with the whole process.

01/21/2023

Dr. Nightingale is always very kind and attentive, listens to me, addresses any issues, refers me to good specialists if needed, and i don't have to wait to get an appointment.

12/24/2022

Friendly

12/19/2022

Take the time to listen and explain

12/16/2022

Very helpful, fast and respectful! A positive experience

12/15/2022

You should have more doctors like him

11/21/2022

Very satisfied

11/14/2022

Issue is long standing

11/14/2022

JUST PROVIDES ANY INFO I NEED TO LISTEN TOO

11/13/2022

I feel confident in Dr.Nightengale.

10/21/2022

He’s the best and I trust him

09/21/2022

Very happy with service and people.

08/11/2022

Great

08/11/2022

I have always found Dr. Nightingale and his staff to be very responsive, friendly and attentive to my questions or needs.

08/09/2022

Each provider was great from check-in to check-out.

08/08/2022

Great medical knowledge too!

07/05/2022

VERY pleased always, with dr. & receptionists.

06/26/2022

Dr Nightgale is always friendly courteous polite and cares about my well-being and my health

06/22/2022

Great

06/16/2022

Doctor and nurse, staff all did a great job.

06/09/2022

I feel very comfortable & respected there

06/04/2022

I am a new patient and have only seen the doctor 2 times .Most of these questions schooling and such I decline to answer, have nothing to do with my health

05/28/2022

He is kind and gives a thorough exam. But don't feel he is very up to date

05/17/2022

From clerk at sign then nurse to doctor everyone was pleasant and professional.

05/12/2022

GOOD

04/21/2022

Dr. Nightingale and the staff were great, as always.

04/16/2022

I felt like I was rushed, and when I asked questions regarding the medications I was currently taking and a new medication he was prescribing he acted annoyed that I was asking questions and gave me short answers. I was not happy with the service provided at this appointment.

04/12/2022

This was a routine follow up on medication I am taking, no problems.

04/06/2022

Very positive experience.

03/24/2022

This was my first visit with Dr. Knightingale. He discussed all issues that concern my health. He seems to be thorough , friendly and show concern where needed.

03/23/2022

Friendly, knowledgeable took very good care of me, service A-1.

02/23/2022

It was a good experience.

02/23/2022

I've been going to *Dr. Nightingale for many years and until he returns, I will continued to go to him. I've trusted *Dr. Nightingale with my life and the lives of my family and will continue to do so.

02/23/2022

*Dr. Nightingale & staff have been very professional & caring.

02/22/2022

Best I've ever had and I'm 69 yrs. old.

02/05/2022

Dr. Nightongale is one of the best when it comes to actually listening.

01/19/2022

All people involved were excellent. Easy to talk too, I wasn't nervous. Polite and very professional.

01/17/2022

Very pleased

01/16/2022

I told dr nightingale that I seemed like my head was stuffed and seemed like it wasn't hear properly He said I might have allergies and to start taking over the counter allergy meds Since taking them I feel a hundred times better Thank you for listening to me and helping me with my congestion problems

12/30/2021

Excellent care. No waiting time. I did not feel rushed at all.

12/28/2021

Dr. Nightingale is wonderful

12/23/2021

The doctor is nice and he knows what is good for me and care.

12/10/2021

Very good.

11/22/2021

I have been with Dr. Luke forever. I fully trust his judgement and he never leaves a stone unturned in finding out what is going on with me.

10/29/2021

Smooth, fast, and friendly

10/28/2021

All my visits to all my doctors offices have always been a very professional, friendly & pleasant experience.

10/08/2021

Dr. Nightingale has always been attentive,compassionate and thorough.

10/08/2021

My concerns at this visit were listened to and dealt with in a very caring manner. Dr Nightingale presented options and discussed how to proceed with my care until my next follow up appointment.

09/21/2021

*Dr. Nightingale is an excellent doctor and nice person in general.

09/21/2021

The dr. is always prompt, courteous, professional, and takes time to answer all my concerns.

09/17/2021

This was my first visit with Dr. Nightingale. He seems to be a competent physician as well as a pleasant man.

09/16/2021

*Luke is excellent. He has been my primary care provider for over 20 yrs.

09/05/2021

Could not have been better.

08/20/2021

Always professional and understanding.

05/24/2021

I find the doctor very easy to speak to and listens to any concerns or questions that I have.

05/18/2021

Doctor, nurse & staff are always very courteous, professional & helpful.

05/17/2021

Professional & courteous.

05/14/2021

Very well pleased. Checks on me often.

05/14/2021

Was the top care for me thank you.

05/05/2021

hes awesome great understanding honest doctor

05/05/2021

Very friendly, and caring, asked alot of questions and answered any question i had.

05/02/2021

Doctor spent a lot of time with me for the physical and I felt he was fairly thorough. For the first time meeting him, I came away with the impression that he is very cynical but not disinterested in my wellbeing.

04/23/2021

I feel that *Dr. Nightingale is a good caring dr., and that any concerns I may have he's very tentative. I will continue to have him as my primary doctor.

04/17/2021

Dr. Nightingale was, as always, knowledgable, attentive, and pleasant. He is aware of my several health challenges and continues to offer excellent guidance and advice.

04/09/2021

I've been with Dr. Nightingale for 25+ years. There's a reason for that. He's very professional, compassionate and understanding. I couldn't ask for anything else!

04/01/2021

great office. great provider.

03/20/2021

Dr Nightengale's Office and Staff are an asset to our community. We are fortunate to have them available.

03/19/2021

Dr. Nightengale and his staff are the best around. They are always extremely caring and efficient

03/08/2021

Dr. Nightingale always takes the time to listen and explain things. The staff is always very friendly and accomadating.

03/05/2021

Great bedside manner all around. Every staff member was very polite and helpful.

03/04/2021

excellent no problems with the office

02/23/2021

overall excellent experience the doctor was very nice and so was the staff. from the nurse to the front desk very respectful and courteous.

02/23/2021

Very Professional

02/17/2021

I enjoy seeing Dr. Nightingale and his staff

02/16/2021

I was very pleased on the professional way everyone was. and I commended Dr. Nightingale for the way he treated me last January when, I believe I had Covid 19, even before we knew it was in the USA.

01/15/2021

Dr. Nightingale is a great physician who listens to your needs and takes time with you. We did NOT feel as if we were being rushed through the office. Very pleased with this appointment, office, and provider!!!!

01/05/2021

Wonderful!

01/04/2021

Dr Nightingale always listens to my concerns and is compassionate
Show more
Online Scheduling 518-664-3242

Dismiss Modal

Close 

Where would you like to share?